
Reverse-Seared Ribeye for the Crew
Smoked then seared boneless ribeyes, compound butter, for ten
Steakhouse crust with smoker depth—ten ribeyes, one plan
Why crews like it: Reverse sear gives even edge-to-edge pink and a real crust. Steaks hold tented at 170°F up to 20 minutes without overcooking if pulled right.
1023Cal
67gProtein
7gCarbs
79gFat
Ingredients
- 8 pieces Boneless Ribeye Steaks
- 2.6 Tbsp Kosher Salt
- 1 3/4 Tbsp Coarse Black Pepper
- 7/8 Tbsp Smoked Paprika
- 7/8 Tbsp Garlic Powder
- 2.6 Tbsp Neutral Oil
- 6.8 Tbsp Unsalted Butter
- 1 3/4 Tbsp Fresh Rosemary
- 2 whole Garlic Cloves
Instructions
- Season the ribeyes: Pat steaks dry. Coat with oil, then salt, pepper, paprika, and garlic powder on all sides. Rest 20 minutes at room temp.
- Smoke low at 225°F: Smoke steaks at 225°F until internal temp reaches 130°F, about 45–55 minutes (115°F if the crew wants medium-rare).
- Compound butter: Mix softened butter, rosemary, and minced garlic. Roll into a log or keep soft for finishing.
- Sear hard: Sear in screaming-hot cast iron or over grill at 500°F+ 90 seconds per side until crust forms and internal hits 145°F (63°C); rest 3 minutes. Medium-rare (130°F) is a preference below the USDA safe minimum, not for anyone pregnant, older, or immunocompromised.
- Butter baste: Add compound butter to pan off direct flame; tilt and baste steaks 30 seconds. Rest 5 minutes tented with foil.
- Hold at 170°F: If holding, tent with foil and place in 170°F oven up to 20 minutes. Do not exceed 145°F internal on the line.
- Tonight's board: Steaks on a board with extra compound butter melting on top. Call temps: 145°F pull (130°F for medium-rare on request).
- Leftovers: Slice cold for steak sandwiches with horseradish mayo. Reheat gently in au jus—don't re-sear.
Tonight's spread
- Ribeyes on a board with compound butter.
- Grilled asparagus and garlic bread.
Firehouse tips
- 130°F off the smoker + hard sear lands at 145°F; pull at 115°F instead for medium-rare.
- Dry surface = better crust; pat again before searing.
- Don't skip the rest or juices run when you cut on the line.
Meal prep
Season early. Smoke in batches if smoker space is tight. Sear to order if possible; otherwise hold tented at 170°F max 20 minutes.
Leftovers
- Steak and egg breakfast sandwiches.
- Slice over a wedge salad with blue cheese.
- smoker
- cast iron or grill
- instant-read thermometer
- sheet pans
- tongs
Related recipes
Browse more